Winter 2013-2014: Sea Ice Loss Locks Jet Stream into Severe Winter Storm Pattern For Most of US

It happened to Europe last year. A persistent erosion of Arctic sea ice set off changes to the polar jet stream that locked in place a severe winter weather pattern that pummeled the central and western European countries for much of the winter. Storm after storm piled snow high in locations that typically saw only modest winter precipitation while other areas were simply buried. The US also took a glancing blow from this extreme storm configuration. But now, with a large trough in the polar Jet remaining locked in place for almost a year, the US from the Rockies eastward appears to be in the line of fire for some very severe winter weather.

In other regions from Alaska to Eastern Europe, record or near record warmth and dryness have settled in with a large swath of eastern Europe showing average temperatures more than 6 degrees Celsius above the seasonal average. Over the extreme northern Pacific, adjacent to Alaska and the Bering Sea, seasonal temperature range from 4-12 degrees Celsius above average. And it is this extreme northward invasion of warm air that is displacing polar and Arctic air masses toward the east and south, putting much of the US in the firing line for strange and severe winter weather.

Just this week, the tale was one of record ice storms throughout the central and eastern US with hundreds of flights cancelled, deadly traffic pile-ups, and holiday shopping disrupted. On the east coast, from Virginia to Maine, workers and shoppers alike were treated to three days straight of snow turning to sleet and freezing rain and then turning back again to snow. With storms like these hitting in early December and with the pattern in the Jet Stream taking on such an extreme configuration, it appears possible that the winter of 2013-2014 could be a very, very stormy one indeed.

A Tale of Jet Streams and Melting Sea Ice

To understand how human caused global warming can make winter storms more severe in some areas while other areas hardly experience winter at all, one should first take a look at two major governors of Northern Hemisphere weather: the circumpolar Jet Stream and Arctic sea ice.

An extreme difference between the temperatures at high northern latitudes and at more temperate latitudes has driven a very rapid flow of upper level air called the Jet Stream for almost all of human meteorological reckoning. This high temperature difference drove powerful upper level winds from west to east. These winds tended to modulate only slightly and when they did, powerful weather events tended to occur.

Locking a greater portion of this cold air in place was the northern hemisphere ice cap, most of which was composed of a large swath of sea ice covering much of the northern oceans. This high volume of cold, reflective ice kept temperatures up north very, very low and provided the massive temperature differences which kept the Jet Stream predominantly flat with only occasional and more moderate severe weather causing ripples and bulges.

But since 1979, massive volumes of sea ice have been lost due to an immense and ongoing human caused warming trend taking hold in the Arctic. As human greenhouse gas emissions sky-rocketed, Arctic temperatures rapidly increased far faster than the global average. By this year, human greenhouse gas emissions had driven CO2 levels to the highest seen in more than 3 million years while Arctic temperatures are now warmer than at any time in the past 150,000 years. Sea ice retreat has been equally unprecedented with average winter values now 15-20% below extent measures seen during 1979 and with end summer sea ice extent values now a stunning 35-50% below that of 1979. Sea ice volume, the measure of total ice including its thickness, has shown even more stunning losses since 1979 with seasonal winter values 30-35% lower than in 1979 and end summer values between 65 and 80% lower during recent years.

JAXA sea ice Dec 9 2013

(Sea ice extent measure composed by JAXA. The light gray dotted line on the top shows sea ice extent averages during the 1980s. The three record lowest years — 2007, 2011 and 2012 — are shown in green, blue, and orange. The most recent year, 2013, is shown in red. Note the persistent and rapid melt trend.)

The loss of hundreds of thousands of square kilometers of sea ice radically reduces the Arctic Ocean’s ability to keep the Arctic cold. To the contrary, we see larger areas of open water that, in turn, radiate ocean heat into the atmosphere throughout winter. As a result the temperature difference between the Arctic and temperate regions is less and this, in turn, slows down the Jet Stream.

When the Jet Stream slows, it tends to meander. And when it meanders it creates very deep troughs and very large ridges. In the ridges, we get unseasonably hot temperatures along with increased risk of drought. And in the troughs, Arctic air swoops down to collide with warmer, moist air in a series of powerful storms. During the summer time, the hot, dry zones can bring deadly heat waves, record droughts, and major wildfires while the cooler stormier zones can bring epic rainfall events or even link up with tropical cyclones to result in highly severe hybrid storms. During the winter time, the hot zones can almost completely obliterate the winter season, while the stormy cooler zones can result in snow storm after snow storm.

Don’t believe me? Then take a look at what weather experts Jeff Masters and Jennifer Francis have to say on the matter:

Polar Warmth and Rossby Wave Pattern Going into Winter 2013-2014

As noted above, a powerful and continuous ridge in the Jet Stream over the north eastern Pacific near Alaska has persistently provided an equally powerful down-sloping trough over much of the US over the past year. The December 10 Jet Stream configuration map shows this pattern remaining locked in place:

Northern Hemisphere Jet Stream 10 Dec 2013

(Image source: California Regional Weather Server)

Note the strong multi-channel ridge to the south of Alaska and to the west of Canada diving down into a deep trough with convergent upper level air flows over the central and eastern US.

On the map, we also see powerful ridges and correlating warmer regions over Europe, Central Asia, and the western Pacific. These large meanders are now typical to the highly weakened Jet Stream pattern we have seen in recent years due to loss of polar sea ice.

Global temperature maps also show anomalously warm temperature departures for much of the Arctic as well as for regions beneath these powerful jet stream ridges. Note that the only northern hemisphere region showing strong anomalously cool conditions is a large swath adjacent to the large trough over North America and southern Greenland.

Global Temperature Averages Dec 1-7 2013

(Global Temperature Averages and Anomalies vs 1981-2010 mean. Image source: NOAA)

Temperature averages in the Arctic region of Kamchatka, the Bering Sea, the Chukchi Sea and Alaska have ranged between 11- and 12 degrees Celsius above average for the first week of December with much of the Arctic showing 4-12 degrees Celsius above average readings. The US and southern Canada, conversely, have shown temperatures 4-10 degress Celsius below average. It is also worth noting the massive swath of 3-12 C above average temperatures stretching all the way from the Middle East to the west coast of Greenland.

Overall, the prevalence of high latitude warmth and a continued high amplitude Rossby wave pattern trough over much of the US is a very conducive pattern for severe winter weather over the coming weeks. Most likely, this pattern will continue to persist through at least early to mid winter. So for the US and especially from the Rockies to the east coast, a progression of strong storms is likely to continue as winter advances.

Links:

California Regional Weather Server

NOAA

PIOMAS

Supporting Research:

Evidence linking Arctic amplification to extreme weather in mid-latitudes

Impact of sea ice cover changes on Northern Hemisphere atmospheric winter circulation

Impact of declining sea ice on winter snowfall cover

Weather extremes provoked by trapping giant waves in the atmosphere

Quasi-resonant amplification of planetary waves and recent Northern Hemisphere weather extremes.

About these ads
Leave a comment

26 Comments

  1. Steve

     /  December 10, 2013

    Nice to read your work again Robert! Hope you are doing well! Have you came across any studies that compare fluctuations in the Jet Stream recently compared to how it flowed say 20 years ago? I’m curious how often extreme movement in the stream occurs when compared to the past. Thanks Steve

    Reply
    • Hello Steve. Good to see you about. I’ve added papers related to this issue. The content and quality of the research continues to progress. That said, this is still a new field and, once entirely validated, it is likely that a new regime will have taken hold as larger volumes of ice melt create another, related but markedly different variety of extreme weather event.

      Reply
  2. james cole

     /  December 10, 2013

    From the above information we can assume that the warmer arctic due directly to global warming from CO2 is the direct cause of the increase in Jet Stream fluctuations. Explained simply by the higher the temp difference between high and lower latitudes the greater force keeping the jet stream in a fast and steady course, the opposite is now the norm. My question is, since we are assured now that CO2 will continue it’s faster rise, the arctic will melt faster and the forces that keep the jet stream up to speed and on a steady course will decline faster and faster. What do models tell us the jet stream will be like when we reach ice free summers, and with ice free summers, we can assume even more rapid warming u there. How out of whack can the jet stream get, could it ever collapse and just go random in all directions at a very slow rate of speed. Sort of like Puff, it’s gone out! No real jet stream to speak of, what then. Could the arctic begin a massive heat up and temperature differences become small enough to kill off a ribust jet stream setting up again?

    Reply
    • The studies show the Jet becoming less stable, weaker and slowly shifting to Greenland (where the colder air becomes centered). After that point, you hit a strange dynamic as cold water outflows from Greenland continue to increase. Cold water in the vicinity of Greenland and the North Atlantic create a very high temperature differential to the tropics, which at this point, have begun to heat up at a more rapid pace. The powerful and volatile atmospheric dynamic created by these conditions result in model depictions of frontal storms with the strength of hurricanes that stretch out over thousands of miles. It is these kinds of storms that were the reason for James Hansen to write his pivotal work “Storms of My Grandchildren.”

      Another way to think of it is that the poles warm first and fastest. But at some point there is a strong negative feedback as the ice begins to rapidly melt, slowing or slightly reversing the Arctic temperature increase as the ice releases its stored cold. So you end up with a see-saw affect in the Arctic that is very unstable. In addition, the center of cold air will change from a polar orbit to a more lopsided one (offset to Greenland). The result will be very unstable weather and radical changes to the Jet which will continue to be mangled by the forces of human caused change in ways that are entirely non-linear.

      It is worth noting that the studies showing Jet Stream weakening due to polar amplification have yet to be proven in the scientific consensus. That said, weakness/blocking patterns in the Jet Stream has been predictive for various extreme events over the past few years and have also occurred in conjunction with high level heat anomalies in the Arctic. Critics of Francis and other polar amplification studies note that Francis has not proposed a mechanism and only relies on correlation. This is not entirely true. The mechanism proposed involves the basic dynamic that drives the Jet Stream — difference in temperature from north to south. Francis proposes that the mechanism of higher relative heat content at the poles tends to slow the Jet Stream down, resulting in various weather changes — including more persistent weather patterns.

      For my part, it seems to me that the Jet Stream model is predictive — at least to the extent that high amplitude Rossby type waves have coincided with extreme events as well as a number of powerful warm air invasions into the Arctic. There is a flurry of study ongoing regarding this subject. So we should see quite a lot of confusion over the coming years as different studies attack the issue from different angles. It generally takes about 20 years for a consensus to develop. In my view, by that time, the trend will have changed to a melt-driven weather dynamic rather than a heat driven weather dynamic. Ironically, there’s more support in some of the models for a melt driven dynamic.

      Oh, and one more thing to think about… The term mechanism can also be used to refer to a proposed physical mechanism that creates the proposed changes in a given model run. In my view, the models, no matter how well done, are simulations and that observation should hold sway — not model results.

      (updated Dec 11)

      Reply
  3. lanikk

     /  December 11, 2013

    Can you describe the effects around the equator and in the Southern Hemisphere? Are there any writings on it?

    Reply
    • The dynamics at the equator and within the southern hemisphere will be different. For one, the south polar ice sheet will, likely (according to models) be slower to respond than the northern hemisphere ice sheets. Nonetheless, polar amplification will probably have a similar effect on jet stream patterns initially. Large melt pulses from west Antarctica, according to model runs, are shown to have a similar dynamic to that of Greenland but on a slower time-frame (depending on aggregate rate of ice sheet response).

      The equator will see slower increases in temperatures but a higher frequency of extreme drought, heatwave, and precipitation events. There is a moderate to high risk of increasing tropical cyclone severity with the potential for very severe storms at the end of the model run period. Cyclone forecasts are uncertain due to added atmospheric factors including the potential for increasing atmospheric dust. However, increasing water temperatures at the equator will likely drive more powerful storms when they do form and result in an increasing length of seasons during which storms can form. Some basins will probably see year-round cyclone formation (this appears to already be happening in the Eastern Pacific).

      As polar amplification ramps down with increasing ice sheet melt more heat concentrates in the tropics and at the equator. So increasing risks for more rapid rates of temperature increase occur at around the three decade horizon onwards.

      It is worth noting that there is now consensus among the scientific community that droughts and heatwaves are increasing in frequency, while the flood issue is still up in the air (community consensus still divided on the issue). It is likely, should current trends continue, that more consensus on increased floods will develop over the coming years. The research supported by Francis and Masters is also still rather new and controversial. So it will take time for consensus to develop.

      From a risk standpoint, there appears a high likelihood that Francis and Master’s analysis is correct and should be taken into account for current and future forecasts.

      Reply
  4. Reblogged this on digger666.

    Reply
  5. A new study for the first time found links between the rapid loss of snow and sea ice cover in the Arctic and a recent spate of exceptional extreme heat events in North America, Europe, and Asia. The study adds to the evidence showing that the free-fall in summer sea ice extent and even sharper decline in spring snow cover in the Northern Hemisphere is reverberating throughout the atmosphere, making extreme events more likely to occur.

    The study, published Sunday in the journal Nature Climate Change, is the first to find correlations between rapid Arctic warming and extreme summer weather events, since previous research had focused on the links between Arctic warming and fall and winter weather patterns.
    http://www.climatecentral.org/news/new-study-adds-to-arctic-warming-extreme-weather-debate-16811

    Reply
    • The Jet Stream studies are shaking up the mainstream a bit. Good. It will be worthwhile seeing a real scientific debate as opposed to the usual scientist versus climate change denier nonsense.

      Reply
  6. Arctic Alaska Warmth

    Although the cold temperatures in the central and western contiguous U.S. have been remarkable this past week, the coldest since December 1990 for portions of California and Oregon, they are not as anomalous as the amazing warmth that briefly affected the Arctic region of Alaska. At around 9 p.m. local time on December 7th the temperature reached 39°F with rain falling at Deadhorse, the airport that serves Prudhoe Bay on the shore of the Arctic Ocean. This was the warmest December temperature ever measured at the site since it was established in 1968 (actually there have been three sites in the Prudhoe Bay area since 1968: Prudhoe Bay ARCO site 1968-1986, Prudhoe Bay WRCC/GHCN site 1986-1999, and the Deadhorse Airport site 1999-current). Prior to the 39° on Saturday night, the warmest temperature measured during December at any of the three sites was 35°F (1.7°C) on December 31, 1973 at the ARCO site. All-time December warmth records were also set or tied at Barter Island AFB (Kaktovik) which reached 37°F (2.8°C), tying its record for the month last set also on December 31, 1973 (POR 1949-current) and Wainright (POR since 1949) with a 32°C (0°C) reading (previous record 30°F on Dec. 1 and 2, 2006 and December 9, 1963). Barrow, which has the longest POR (since 1921) of any site on Alaska’s Arctic Ocean shore, reached 30°, short of their December record of 34° set on December 9, 1932. Checking the December data for ALL of the Arctic shore sites in Alaska (Barrow, Kuparuk, Prudhoe Bay (Deadhorse), Barter Island, Colville Village, Nuiqsut, Wainwright, and Point Lay) it appears the 39°F reading at Deadhorse was the warmest December temperature ever observed at any site along the shores of Alaska’s Arctic Ocean. Some RAWS sites along the Dalton Highway south of Prudhoe Bay measured temperatures into the 40°s according to Rick Thoman of NWS-Fairbanks.
    http://www.wunderground.com/blog/weatherhistorian/comment.html?entrynum=222#commenttop

    Reply
  7. “There is also a very strong relationship with winds and sea level, according to Trenberth. Water is piling up in the western Pacific Ocean at a rate of around 10mm per year which is three times the global average. This has led to a difference in sea level, measured by satellite radars, between the western and eastern Pacific. “The sea level is 20cm higher in the western Pacific and the only way to keep it there is for strong winds to pile up the water. It is these changes in the winds that change the ocean currents and affect where the heat is going,” he explained. “But this can’t keep going for ever. The ocean wants to slop back to the east.”

    Trenberth points to three lines of evidence that support this idea: measurable and recorded changes in the wind strength, satellite altimeter radar measurements of sea level and an analysis of ocean heat data
    http://www.reportingclimatescience.com/news-stories/article/global-warming-pause-due-to-pacific-says-trenberth.html

    Reply
  8. December 2013


    Three years of observations by ESA’s CryoSat satellite show that the West Antarctic Ice Sheet is losing over 150 cubic kilometres of ice each year – considerably more than when last surveyed.

    http://www.esa.int/Our_Activities/Observing_the_Earth/CryoSat/Antarctica_s_ice_loss_on_the_rise

    Alpine glacier, unchanged for thousands of years, now melting

    New ice cores suggest Alps have been strongly warming since 1980s

    http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2013-12/osu-agu_1121113.php

    Reply
  9. The AGU meeting is throwing off all sorts of new information , and none of it is good news.
    This wasn’t part of the AGU :
    Previous estimates put the amount of heat accumulated by the world’s oceans over the past decade equivalent to about 4 Hiroshima atomic bomb detonations per second, on average, but Trenberth’s research puts the estimate equivalent to more than 6 detonations per second.
    http://www.theguardian.com/environment/climate-consensus-97-per-cent/2013/dec/10/global-warming-unpaused-fast-forward

    Reply
    • Can you give a good summary of what’s going on over at AGU? Nose deep in another methane post which, though I hope it doesn’t, will probably piss someone off.

      Not feeling quite as depressed for some reason. Maybe comfortable denial has re-asserted itself.

      Best

      R

      Reply
  10. Because this is all so depressing -

    Reply
  11. Jet stream loops -
    The temperatures in northern Sweden have been on a roller coaster so far this month. One site, Nikkaluokta saw its temperature fall from 4.7°C (40.5°F) on December 3rd to -40.8°C (-41.4°F) on December 9th only to then rise to a maximum of 7.7°C (45.9°F) on December 11th, an amazing rise of 48.5°C (87.3°F) in just under 48 hours!

    http://www.wunderground.com/blog/weatherhistorian/comment.html?entrynum=224#commenttop

    Reply
  1. Winter 2013-2014: Sea Ice Loss Locks Jet Stream into Severe Winter Storm Pattern For Most of US
  2. Baby, it’s cold outside! Debunking Climate Change Denial | The Secular Jurist
  3. Cold Snap For US? It’s the Global Warming-Induced COLLAPSING Polar Vortex, Stupid | robertscribbler
  4. This is What Human-Caused Climate Change Looks Like: Arctic to Warm, West Coast to Bake, Polar Vortex to Collapse and Flood Eastern US With Arctic Air | robertscribbler
  5. Polar Vortex to Collapse and Flood Eastern US With Arctic Air | ClimateState
  6. Arctic ‘Heat Wave’ to Rip Polar Vortex in Half, Shatter Alaska’s All-Time Record High for January? | robertscribbler
  7. Arctic ‘Heat Wave’ to Rip Polar Vortex in Half, Shatter Alaska’s All-Time Record High for January? | 2 Degrees Centigrade
  8. Dr Jennifer Francis and the Year-Long Blocking Pattern | robertscribbler

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 3,614 other followers

%d bloggers like this: